a blog of hymn histories and meditations

  • HOME
  • BIO
  • GALLERY
  • HYMN SITES
  • PREVIOUS POSTS

What modern hymn links the Great Commandment with the Great Commission?

November 1, 2018 By Pam McAllister

PAM’S THOUGHTS ON THE HYMN TEXT

Window in St. Patrick's Cathedral, El Paso, TX
Window in St. Patrick’s Cathedral, El Paso, TX

As Matthew tells it at the very end of his book, after Mary Magdalene and “the other Mary” encountered the risen Jesus on Easter morning, they ran to tell the disciples. Astonished, the men made their way up a mountain in Galilee, where Jesus gave them the Great Commission — to spread his teachings to all the nations.

In 1978, British-American Jeffery Rowthorn wrote a hymn text to fit the tune ABBOT’S LEIGH — “LORD, YOU GIVE THE GREAT COMMISSION.” The words make clear that the mission of the church is to build a just society, one of mercy and love. Each of the five verses ends with the prayer, “With the Spirit’s gifts empower us / For the work of ministry.” 

GREAT COMMISSION + GREAT COMMANDMENT

As I write this, U.S. citizens are preparing for another election deemed “crucial.” Once again, Christians seem to be split between those who stress the Great Commission (to evangelize — make disciples, baptize, preach) and those who emphasize the Great Commandment (to serve — love God and love your neighbor as yourself). Our attitude about these two strongly influences our faith perspective. 

In a magazine interview (linked below), Dr. Diana Butler Bass, scholar of American religion and a leading voice for progressive Christianity, explained the problem of excluding one or the other:

The Great Commission without the Great Command is intolerance, militarism, and crusades. The Great Command to love God and love your neighbor, without the Great Commission, on the other hand, can wind up being kind of self-centered, but at least it’s a loving, isolated reality.

Bishop Jeffery Rowthorn neatly folds the commandment into the commission in this hymn text, written expressly for the tune ABBOT’S LEIGH. Born in Wales in 1934, Rowthorn studied at Cambridge, Oxford, and Union Theological Seminary, served as both priest and professor on both sides of the Atlantic, and was a founding faculty member of the Institute of Sacred Music at Yale in 1973. He was named Bishop in Charge of the Convocation of American Churches in Europe in 1994. 

DEANNA’S NOTES ON THE HYMN TUNE 

British composer and Anglican priest Cyril Taylor (1907-1991) wrote the tune ABBOT’S LEIGH in 1941 during World War II. Taylor was working at the time as the BBC’s producer of religious broadcasting. “Abbot’s Leigh” is the name of a village near Bristol where the BBC was based during the war.

While “Lord, You Give the Great Commission” is a much-loved text paired with ABBOT’S LEIGH, the reason that the tune came into being had its roots in another text, “Glorious Things of Thee are Spoken.” Apparently the BBC was  receiving complaints during the war regarding its broadcasting “Glorious Things” as sung to the tune AUSTRIA (the melody of the Austrian national anthem). Taylor penned ABBOT’S LEIGH to be an alternative tune to be sung with “Glorious Things.”

ABBOT’S LEIGH first appeared in several early hymnals from the 1950s, including the BBC Hymn Book (the BBC has a hymn book! This is cool!). This hymn tune is a 20th century staple in many modern hymnals. It’s also the only non-public domain tune on my trio recording, Makes the Heart to Sing: Jazz Hymns.

TO GO DEEPER

Words and music on the Hymnary website

“Hopeful Discontent: Tracing Spirituality in Christian History with Diana Butler Bass” Interview with Joelle Chase, Spectrum Magazine, September, 2014

A People’s History of Christianity: The Other Side of the Story by Diana Butler Bass, HarperCollins, 2009. My favorite of Bass’s books, this is the story of our faith told in the same spirit as Howard Zinn’s 1980 classic text The People’s History of the United States.

 

BBC Hymn Book

Audio track of ABBOT’S LEIGH from Makes the Heart to Sing: Jazz Hymns

Sheet music of Deanna’s arrangement of ABBOT’S LEIGH

Filed Under: Blog Post Tagged With: ABBOT’S LEIGH, AUSTRIA, BBC Hymn Book, Cyril Taylor, Deanna Witkowski, Diana Butler Bass, Glorious Things of Thee are Spoken, Jeffery Rowthorn, Lord You Give the Great Commission, Makes the Heart to Sing

Contact

Pam McAllister info@AskHerAboutHymn.com

PREVIOUS HYMN QUESTIONS

  • What Social Gospel hymn calls on progressive Christians to challenge the status quo?
  • What hymn for world peace was written by a US Army veteran and former prisoner of war?
  • What Spanish hymn reminds us that we encounter God on our life journeys through acts of kindness and generosity?

Popular Tags

Advent hymn African-American spiritual Black Lives Matter Brian Wren Brooklyn Botanic Garden C. Austin Miles C. Michael Hawn Charles Wesley Christ Is Alive Deanna Witkowski Diana Butler Bass Doreen Ketchens Easter hymn For the Beauty of the Earth George Whitefield God of Grace and God of Glory Hanson Place Baptist Church Homeless Jesus hymn history hymn meditation hymn meditation by Pam McAllister Hymn Society hymn story hymn story by Pam McAllister I Come to the Garden Alone In the Garden James H. Cone Mahalia Jackson Makes the Heart to Sing Makes the Heart to Sing Jazz Hymns Mark Miller Martin Luther King Martin Luther King assassination Martin Luther King Jr. Mary Magdalene Medina United Methodist Church Pam McAllister Pam McAllister hymn meditation Pam McAllister hymn story Park Slope United Methodist Church Prophet Jeremiah Robert Lowry Shall We Gather At the River Social Gospel The Church of Gethsemane

Copyright © 2025 · Beautiful Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in