a blog of hymn histories and meditations

  • HOME
  • BIO
  • GALLERY
  • HYMN SITES
  • PREVIOUS POSTS

What happened to the “Amens”?

September 8, 2016 By Pam McAllister

hm25-linda-woods-amenScholars believe that “Amen” may be the most widely known word in human speech. “Amen” means yes, so be it, verily, I believe it.

One of the most beautiful passages in the Bible is 2 Corinthians 1:20: “For in Jesus, every one of God’s promises is a ‘Yes.’ For this reason it is through him that we say the ‘Amen,’ to the glory of God.”

Christians aren’t the only ones who say it. Jews and Muslims use “Amen” as a concluding word in prayers, too. It is likely derived from the Hebrew word emuna which means faith or emet which means truth.

Pronunciations vary. If you’re singing something by Handel, the word is pronounced “ah-men.” In gospel music, it’s usually “ay-men.” Muslims usually say “ah-meen.” Jews pronounce it “ah-main.”

In all its variations, the word lives on — but no longer at the end of our hymns. What happened?

IF YOU’RE HAPPY AND YOU KNOW IT …

hm25-music-amenWhen I was a kid at the Medina United Methodist Church, just a few blocks from the Erie Canal, halfway between Rochester and Buffalo, we always ended our Sunday morning hymns with an “Amen.”

Sometimes, they were long and drawn out, in wobbly, full vibrato and dramatic voices. Other times, the amens were short and sweet. Almost always, there was modulating harmony from the altos and basses in the congregation. Now, it seems, we haven’t sung a closing “amen” in years, except to end the Doxology. What happened?

FOLLOW THE LEADER

hm25-green-amenIn 1861, Hymns Ancient and Modern was published for use in the Church of England. The editors of this hymnal added “Amen” to the end of every hymn, thinking to revive a tradition from the Middle Ages. Later, British hymn scholars concluded that this was an historical error and, in the 1920s, nixed the use of “Amen.” After all, Martin Luther didn’t sing amen, nor did Isaac Watts or the Wesley brothers.

Following their British cousins, American Protestants tacked amens on the end of hymns from the 1880s to the 1970s, when they, too, reversed course. One by one, the denominational hymnals were published without amens — first the Episcopalians (1982), then the Methodists (1989) and the Presbyterians (1990).

Now, when we hear an Amen, it is usually spoken at the end of our prayers or shouted out by an enthusiastic member of the congregation or sung in elaborate harmonies as a choral response — a Three-Fold or Seven-Fold Amen, uplifting and fun to sing.

Amen!

AMENS ON YOUTUBE


“The Lord Bless You and Keep You” Westminster Choir College


“Amen” from Lilies of the Field” with Sidney Poitier, 1963


“St Paul’s Cathedral Choir, Amen”

Acknowledgement: Amen art at top of post is by Linda Woods.

Filed Under: Blog Post Tagged With: 2 Corinthians 1:20, Amen hymn ending, Hymns Ancient and Modern, Medina United Methodist Church

Contact

Pam McAllister info@AskHerAboutHymn.com

PREVIOUS HYMN QUESTIONS

  • What Social Gospel hymn calls on progressive Christians to challenge the status quo?
  • What hymn for world peace was written by a US Army veteran and former prisoner of war?
  • What Spanish hymn reminds us that we encounter God on our life journeys through acts of kindness and generosity?

Popular Tags

Advent hymn African-American spiritual Black Lives Matter Brian Wren Brooklyn Botanic Garden C. Austin Miles C. Michael Hawn Charles Wesley Christ Is Alive Deanna Witkowski Diana Butler Bass Doreen Ketchens Easter hymn For the Beauty of the Earth George Whitefield God of Grace and God of Glory Hanson Place Baptist Church Homeless Jesus hymn history hymn meditation hymn meditation by Pam McAllister Hymn Society hymn story hymn story by Pam McAllister I Come to the Garden Alone In the Garden James H. Cone Mahalia Jackson Makes the Heart to Sing Makes the Heart to Sing Jazz Hymns Mark Miller Martin Luther King Martin Luther King assassination Martin Luther King Jr. Mary Magdalene Medina United Methodist Church Pam McAllister Pam McAllister hymn meditation Pam McAllister hymn story Park Slope United Methodist Church Prophet Jeremiah Robert Lowry Shall We Gather At the River Social Gospel The Church of Gethsemane

Copyright © 2025 · Beautiful Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in